Homophobia:
Unlucky Us
by Robert L.
Tufford
The Past: Them
Living for a while in Germany 20 years after World War II, I repeatedly got the same story
from Germans about their experience of the end of the war.
"When I heard it was over, that Germany
had surrendered, it was as if the world had ended," they would all say. "I
didn't think it was possible for Germany to lose. With years of Nazi propaganda about
German invincibility and German superiority, I could not accept the reality of defeat and
surrender. It was as if the world I knew so well was gone. Everything I had believed was
not only wrong, it had vanished. I felt my life was over. I continued to live only because
my body lived. And then I slowly began to construct a new world of beliefs. It took a long
time."
An old story, really, this business of a
forced encounter with a reality which shatters one's beliefs, but no less painful for
being so common in human experience. We've all had similar trauma, though perhaps not
often with the intensity described by the survivors of Nazi Germany.
Other examples abound throughout history. Two
large-scale examples probably match the German experience.
In the United States, both slave owners and
former slaves experienced total cognitive dissonance with the defeat of the South and the
end of legal slavery. America still struggles, 150 years later, still copes with the
dangerous institutional and emotional remnants of that trauma.
Jung Chang's remarkable novel, Wild Swans,
a three-generation story of China in the 20th century, puts the reader in the gripping,
vivid, and terrifying reality of surging hope followed by bottomless despair as the whole
country was repeatedly swept by change, growth, collapse, change, growth collapse.
Recovery from such trauma comes in stages:
1. Despair: My world has vanished. What do I
do now?
2. Regret: How could I have believed such nonsense?
3. Fear: What if it happens again?
4. Hope: Now I live with beliefs which will not allow such nonsense.
The Present: Us
People in the developed world have come a long way in discarding old, dangerous beliefs.
Racism and sexism we still have with us, but both prejudices have now been so well- and
widely analyzed and so effectively discredited that even those adults who are still
prejudiced have learned (most of the time) to keep their mouths shut. And large parts of
the world are raising a generation of children (mostly) free of the old stains of hate
based on color and gender.
Lucky us.
We affluent developed societies consider
ourselves fortunate (and we are). Afloat on a sea of education, money, and good luck, we
dangerously see ourselves relatively free of taint. Dangerously?
Dangerously because we unconsciously have set
ourselves up for yet another big fall, another "defeat" which will render old
beliefs useless and new, healthy beliefs very hard to acquire.
One group still qualifies around the
world as the hated Other, more or less freely subject to rejection ranging from
jeers to beatings to murders. Homosexuals continue, despite small areas of progress, to be
the Truly Loathed, the Despicably Queer, the Artsy-fartsy Fairies.
Homophobia is the last remaining hate that is
so deep, so pervasive that it can poison everything. The reasons for this are many, and
gruesomely fascinating, but are not my point here.
My point is this: the continuing unexamined
acceptance of homosexual hate is, because it is profoundly and totally irrational, as much
a threat to present society as racism and sexism once were.
Easy to say, but what's the proof?
The proof is in your reaction
to:
Photographs of Matthew Shepard's body on the
icy fence in Wyoming.
Encounters with people with AIDS.
Two women or two men kissing in a sitcom or
a movie.
Close-up color photographs of genitals
of persons of your gender.
The possibility of homosexuals as legal
members of the armed forced.
Homosexual teachers in elementary schools.
Anal sex.
Germans under the Nazis had a hard time seeing
Jews as people. American southerners had a hard time seeing slaves as people.
Even large parts of the developed world today
have a hard time seeing queers as people.
Why? Because homosexuals do to other
men what men historically did to women:
1. Objectify, and
2. Penetrate.
Sexist men see women as objects, things, to be
admired, possessed, and used. Sexist men desire, for their own pleasure, to penetrate the
bodies of these objects. Sexist men (and "their" women who have bought into and
"thrived" from the system) irrationally fear homosexual men because they fear
that homosexual men will do the same two things to them and, of course, "their"
children. The foolishness of their assumptions is exceeded only by the intensity of their
irrationality.
As Rusty puts it in Myra Breckinridge,
"'Normal' is balling chicks."
It's a warped mindset whose fragile foundation
is equal to that of other violent, warping ideologies from the past.
Harder times is acomin' unless we get our act
together.
Unlucky us.
END
Send this
page to a friend.
We love to get mail
from our readers!

Magellan's
Log IX
Magellan's
Log front page
|