3.
Germany, September 2003
Disapproval of the present Gulf War is high in Germany, around 80%.
Nevertheless, the fascination with all things American that brought me to the United
States still exists among the Germans. It is not restricted to my generation. I have
German friends who could be my sons or daughters who look up to America as their big
brother, just as I did in 1957.
If you stumbled over the expression "big brother" because it reminded you of
George Orwells term in his 1984, you are not entirely off the mark.
Orwells Big Brother instilled fear. Such a fear is developing and eating away the
deep gratitude that most Germans still feel for the American protection against Soviet
domination.
Anti-Americanism has always been present among Germans throughout the 20th
century, from the left and from the right. America represents cultural levelling for the
right, inhumane capitalism for the left. The preemptive Gulf War against Iraq adds a new
dimension to these potential enmities: the fear of American power, the same power that had
been good during the Cold War because of the Germans fear of the Russians. The
victorious Red Army had raped German women en masse in 1945, plundered homes, arbitrarily
abducted Germans, and established a regime in their zone of occupation which repeated
totalitarian practices in the name of anti-fascism. Russians were also, unjustly,
considered culturally inferior by many Germans.
The fear of the Russians is gone now, but the mighty protector retained its power. And
this power, our American power, now dominating the world, begins slowly to replace the
past fear of the Russians. The Germans do not forget that Hitler had wasted the power of
the nation in a senseless war. Thus they, more easily than we, understand that the
politics of power is addictive.
A tribunal in American-occupied Nuremberg executed Nazi politicians and even generals
for German aggressiveness. Following orders was no excuse. The executioner, the hangman,
wore an American helmet, as can be seen in a film that was made in Nuremberg.
When the president of the United States determines that a preemptive war is necessary,
the American satellite country called the Federal Republic of Germany remembers its
gratitude to American power to which it owes its very existence and its unification, but
it also remembers the Nuremberg trials. The present German government refused the order to
invade Iraq. The Germans are scared of war and the federal chancellor had to face an
election.
When I discussed Chancellor Schröders refusal to engage the German military in
Iraq my German brother complained that Schröder could simply have invoked the German
constitution, which defines "defense" narrowly and thus forbids the Chancellor
to participate in a preemptive war. He and others were worried about the German-American
friendship. When I told my friends that I personally do not know any person in this
country who approves Bushs policies they were amazed. The German now have something
like almost a bad conscience for not following the American call to arms. The German
center-right opposition parties expressed their desire for keeping the American government
happy, although they had to balance this with the unpopularity of the Gulf war.
Americans are seen abroad as proudly associated with American power. Are we?
In their politics the Germans are preoccupied by discontent with their government. The
government is a coalition of Social Democrats and Greens. The Social Democrats are
traditionally the party of the working man, and the Greens are concerned with the
environment. The stagnant German economy demands reduction of the generous German social
security system. The present chancellor Schröder is willing to institute the necessary
reforms. But that policy contrasts with the tradition of his party, the protection of the
common man. In other words, the Germans essentially suffer from the same problems we do,
and the questionable solution is the same: tax cuts and borrowing. These problems are not
merely similar to ours, they are rooted in the very global capitalism that our country
stands for.
Political reforms are necessary in Germany because unemployment is very high. Germany
cannot continue to produce high quality manufactured products, export them and pay
middle-class wages and let everyone live happily. The global economy, or free trade, would
not allow that because it forces the German manufacturers, like ours, to export jobs,
because labor plus the social net has become too expensive in Germany. What is happening
in Germany is quite similar to what is happening here at home as a consequence of global
market economy.
But what is the global economy? Is free market economy not the same as universal
capitalism? And who is the champion of universal capitalism? The United States. The
foremost goal of American foreign policy in the 20th century was been the
prevention of large chunks of the earth turning economically in on themselves and become
autarchist. The oppression of the German, French, Polish, Jewish, Japanese and Russian
people by their rulers or German and Japanese occupiers was a much less important reason
for fighting them than the controlled economy that Germany and Japan established in their
empires. The distressing social changes that are forced upon the industrialized nations by
the global economy may very well one day be blamed on the control the United States exerts
over the world through its superior military power.
Eventually free trade may equalize the living standard in the world. But this will take
many generations. In the foreseeable future the United States will increasingly be blamed
for massive social changes in countries like Germany (or France, or Britain, or Canada)
where democracy is based on and fostered by a broad middle class. All the more so since
the United States presents such a bad social example to the world: while the wealth of an
economic upper class increases in leaps and bounds, there are uncountable thousands of
homeless people in the streets of our cities. The global economy reduces and tends to
destroy the American and European middle class which won the Cold War against a so-called
socialist system that had become an attractive instrument for total power in the hands of
its rulers. Now that most of those countries are gone the global problem is our American
power.