Concentrate on whatever
object, movie, book, TV show, or piece of music, art, or whatever you wish to rate. Then
read each statement below and insert a number between 1 and 10 in the blank after each
statement, where 1 means a strong NO!, and 10 means a strong
YES!!!
The letter "X" in each statement refers to the name of whatever work it is that
you're rating.
1. Would the late Michel Foucault have
approved of X? ____
2. If you published a paper in PMLA
or Artforum about X would your salary increase? ____
3. Do you have great admiration for the
creator of X and envy his/her ability to get enough funding to do it? ____
4. Does X re-affirm your belief in the wisdom
of living an over-examined life based on the edicts of people with more money, power,
celebrity, and larger vocabularies than you have? ____
5. Does X move humanity significantly closer
to using every word in the Merriam-Webster 3rd International Dictionary along with quite a
few that aren't? ____
6. Does X lend further support to the validity
of the reductive analysis of cultural phenomena? ____
7. If Derrida could experience X, would he
grin with approval? ____
8. Does your analysis of X significantly
contribute to the discomfort of all scientists and produce public derision on those rare
occasions when anyone in the public pays attention? ____
9. Does X make you feel even better about
devoting your life to the pursuit of the destruction of verbal beauty through the creation
of sentences containing a hundred words or more? ____
10. Does X help you avoid thinking about the
one billion people in the world who are starving? ____
Scoring:
85-100. An intellectual breakthrough of great importance. A
phallic-hegemony-dissolving re-distribution of neo-paradigmatic hyperbole for the ages.
70-84. A work of considerable value but probably to be understood only by the
more mature members of your department.
Below 70. A dangerous and subversive, which is to say, trivial work. At best it
should be destroyed. Certainly you want to protect most children and all graduate students
from it.
Back to Millennial
Culture-at-a-glance
Magellan's Log VI
Magellan's Log front page |