China, AIDS, and Circumcision
The other puzzle is China.Just by sheer number of cases, the African AIDS crisis has
finally entered the worlds consciousness. Chinas turn is coming soon, and it
may well be of a magnitude that dwarfs the tragedy in Africa.
The situation is this. At present, the Chinese government is in almost total denial
that there is an AIDS problem in China. The official government estimate is that there are
only 10,000 people with the virus, out of a population of 1.4 billion. Nothing to worry
about, right?
Wrong. A panel of Chinese physicians in Beijing recently released, at some personal
risk, their own careful study of the situation. Their estimate, which they suspect is low,
is that there are 600,000 HIV positives in China today. Further, these people dont
know they are positive. Thus the number will grow rapidly as they infect others.
Heres the kicker. Of course AIDS is being spread in China in the usual ways (drug
users, sexual contact), but China has added another: the blood supply. The collection of
blood in China has become a very big, often private business. Its easy to make a lot
of money by going into the countryside and collecting blood from peasants and then selling
it to hospitals in the cities. You can even make the same rounds of the same villages
every month or two.
Whats the catch? Disposable needles are even now virtually unknown in
China. Whether private or public, persons involved in the blood supply system
universally re-use the needles. (The writer has a Chinese friend who grew up in an
affluent family in one of the largest coastal cities; he reports that he never saw doctors
use disposable needles even for routine injections.)
So you get 600,000 HIV+ people, which the government says dont exist. Since they
dont exist, the government doesnt need to do much. The AIDS education budget
for China last year was $2 million. Even the few billboards and TV commercials which that
money could buy have been pulled after a few days exposure. Denial, denial, denial.
Add to this the deep, Confucian version of puritanism which you find in China, which is
very much part of official government policy. Remember: The Chinese government fears two
things on the Internet: political information... and pornography. In government eyes, yes,
the New York Times is dangerous. But no more dangerous than superboobs.com, or whatever.
Which brings us to the circumcision pageant thats about to unfold in the early
3rd millennium. The Beijing doctors, in their report, estimate that, if nothing is done,
within ten years China will have more HIV+ people than Africa does now.
This, in a country that has never practiced circumcision, that in fact views it as yet
another example of weird Western barbarism. Yet, based on whats happening in Africa
now, it seems likely that a few years down the road, the world will be clamoring for China
to start cutting. And when you start cutting nationwide in China, the numbers of discarded
foreskins quickly get into nine figures.
China doesnt have the AIDS drugs now. China officially claims it has no AIDS
problem now, or in the foreseeable future. But when the problem finally becomes so great
that it can no longer be denied, the government is going to be faced with one simple,
revealing choice: to cut, or not to cut.
We know how the West, perversely, has decided, time and again. No problem: cut, cut,
cut. How China decides will be one of the more fascinating stories of the new millennium.